Baking potatoes cooked in the embers or over indirect heat until the skin is crisp and the inside is fluffy. Served split with butter and sour cream.
smokeandsoil.com/recipes/fire-baked-potatoes-with-sour-cream
by L Field
Prep
10 min
Cook
45 min
Total
55 min
Serves
4
Level
Hard
Method
BBQ
Ingredients
This is a recipe that only makes sense when potatoes are at their best. The grill doesn’t hide inferior produce — it amplifies it. Choose well and the cooking takes care of itself. Here, the humble potato is elevated through slow, even heat, baked directly in the fire’s residual warmth until it reaches a perfect, fluffy interior wrapped in a crisp, smoky skin.
The method combines direct and indirect heat, allowing you to manage the temperature precisely with a two-zone setup. This balance ensures the potatoes cook through without burning, while the olive oil and salt enhance the natural flavours without masking them. The finishing touch — a dollop of full-fat sour cream, fresh chives, and a scattering of black pepper — keeps the dish clean and straightforward, letting the quality ingredients speak for themselves.
This recipe is a reminder that BBQ isn’t about showmanship or complexity. It’s about patience, respect for the ingredients, and the quiet craft of fire-cooking. When done right, everyday ingredients like potato and apple become something quietly special, the kind of dish that fits seamlessly into any homegrown, seasonal meal.
Ingredients
finely chopped
Health Notes
This is a vegetable-led dish and a naturally lower-calorie option. Grilling with minimal oil preserves the vegetables' nutritional value while adding flavour through caramelisation and char. High in fibre and micronutrients.
Notes
Seasonal Variations
Nutrition (per serving, estimate)
360
kcal
8g
protein
35g
carbs
20g
fat
Values are estimates and vary with portion size and preparation.
Made this recipe?
More Like This
A crisp, refreshing slaw made with crunchy apples and a sharp cider vinegar dressing. The perfect no-cook accompaniment to rich, smoky meats.
A classic, simple apple sauce, perfect for accompanying pork dishes.
Simple balsamic and olive oil dressing perfect for grilled pork steaks and charred radicchio.
Never miss a recipe
Potato Preparation and Fire Setup
Wash and thoroughly dry the potatoes. Prick each potato 8-10 times with a fork; this prevents internal pressure build-up and potential rupture. Rub the potatoes with olive oil and a generous amount of sea salt flakes. Prepare the Weber Master-Touch for a two-zone fire. Fill a chimney starter with Weber briquettes and light. Once fully ashed over, pour the coals onto one side of the charcoal grate. Place the lid on, ensuring the bottom and top vents are half-open, and allow the grill to stabilise at an internal temperature of 190°C (375°F). Add the wood chunk, if using, directly onto the hot coals.
Initial Indirect Bake (Foil-Wrapped)
Wrap each prepared potato tightly in a single layer of heavy-duty aluminium foil. Place the foil-wrapped potatoes on the cooking grate over the indirect heat zone (the side without coals). Close the lid. Maintain the 190°C (375°F) temperature, adjusting the vents as necessary. Cook for 60 minutes. The foil traps steam, ensuring the starch granules fully gelatinise for a fluffy texture.
Final Crisp and Internal Check
After 60 minutes, carefully remove the potatoes from the foil. Return the unwrapped potatoes to the indirect heat zone. Close the lid and cook for a further 15 minutes. This final stage dries the skin, making it crisp and robust. Use the instant-read thermometer to check the internal temperature of the largest potato; it should register 95°C (203°F). If not, continue cooking, checking every 5 minutes.
Final Crisp and Internal Check
After 60 minutes, carefully remove the potatoes from the foil. Return the unwrapped potatoes to the indirect heat zone. Close the lid and cook for a further 15 minutes. This final stage dries the skin, making it crisp and robust. Use the instant-read thermometer to check the internal temperature of the largest potato; it should register 95°C (203°F). If not, continue cooking, checking every 5 minutes.
Health Notes
This is a vegetable-led dish and a naturally lower-calorie option. Grilling with minimal oil preserves the vegetables' nutritional value while adding flavour through caramelisation and char. High in fibre and micronutrients.
Per serving (estimate)
360
kcal
8g
protein
35g
carbs
20g
fat
An instant-read thermometer is the single most reliable tool for achieving precise cooking results over fire. At Smoke & Soil, we champion clean, whole-food cooking that honours seasonal ingredients and respects the natural flavours of your produce. This thermometer fits perfectly into that ethos by taking the guesswork out of doneness, allowing you to cook meats, fish, and even vegetables to perfection every time. It is indispensable for ensuring food safety, particularly with poultry, where undercooking can pose health risks. It also speeds up weeknight cooking by giving you immediate temperature feedback, so you never have to second guess whether your food is ready. Using an instant-read thermometer correctly is as important as owning one. Insert the probe into the thickest part of the meat, avoiding bones which conduct heat differently and give false readings. Take multiple readings to confirm consistency, especially with larger cuts. This tool is not just for meat; it can help you nail the perfect temperature for everything from bread to custards, supporting a wide range of fire-cooking techniques. It is a straightforward way to elevate your BBQ game without fuss or guesswork. The instant-read thermometer embodies the no-nonsense, practical approach Smoke & Soil stands for. It is a tool that rewards attention to detail and encourages respect for the ingredients and the cooking process. Investing in a good quality, fast-reading model will pay dividends in flavour, texture, and safety. It also complements other techniques like carryover cooking and indirect heat methods, making it a versatile addition to your BBQ toolkit.
Written by
L Field
